BACTERIAL EXTRACT FOR THE PREVENTION OF RECURRENT URINARY TRACT INFECTIONS IN
PREGNANT WOMEN: A PILOT STUDY BAERTSCHI R.,' BALMER J.A.,* EDUAH S.B.,3 LlECHTl A.,' LURlE D.,5 SCHAMS H.6
1) Private practice, Yverdon,
Switzerland. 2)
Private practice, Spiez, Switzerland.
Private practice, Friburg, Switzerland. 4) Private practice, Huttwil, Switzerland.
Private practice, Liestal, Switzerland.
6) Private practice, Ilanz,
Switzerland.
Summary: Recurrent urinary tract infections (UTls) are a frequent cause of
concern during pregnancy, and there is a limited choice of appropriate
antibiotic treatments. An alternative approach may be their prevention by an
immunoactive bacterial extract that has already been shown to be safe and
effective in children and adults. Preclinical investigations have demonstrated
the absence of embryotoxic or teratogenic effects. The aim of this open
multicenter pilot study was to investigate the efficacy and safety of the
bacterial extract OM-8930 in pregnant women with recurrent UTls. Sixty-two
patients presenting with an acute UTI in weeks 16 to 28 of pregnancy were
treated with one capsule daily of OM-8930 until delivery. Antibiotics were
given concomitantly for acute infection at entry and when necessaly. After
ently, clinical checks were conducted I week after the end of initial
antibiotic therapy and then every month until 6 weeks after delivery. The
results show that theincidence of UTI recurrences was significantly reduced,
with only 12 patients (19.4%) experiencing a recurrence during the study in
comparison with 32 patients (52.5%)during the 6 months
prior to the study (p = 0.002). The need for antibiotic therapy was also
markedly reduced, with 34 patients (55.7%) requiring antibiotics before the
study compared with eight (12.9%) during the study (p = 0.0002). Slight adverse
events were observed in only two patients (nausea and heartburn). All newborns
were healthy with normal Apgar scores. This pilot study shows that OM-8930
reduces the incidence of UTI recurrences during pregnancy and is well
tolerated. No negative effects in the newborns were observed.
Introduction
Urinary tract infections (UTls) are common in women and are among the most
frequent infections
Address for correspondence: R. Baertschi, Rue du Pre 2, CH-1400 Yverdon, Switzerland.
seen in general practice. Data from the USA indicate
that UTls lead to approximately 8 million consultations per year resulting in
100,000 hospitalizations and a global annual cost of $1.6 billion (1). It is
estimated that 20-30% of all women have one or more episodes of bacteriuria per
year, of which 6% lead to a UTI. Evidence in the literature suggests that 50%
of young women experience a recurrence after 12 months, depending on the
immunocompetence of theurogenital system (2). Around 80-85% of these UTls are
caused by fscherichia coli (3). UTls are also the most frequent infections
during pregnancy, with a prevalence of 5-1 0%. Preexisting asymptomatic
bacteriuria, which outside of pregnancy requires no treatment in the majority
of cases, is often the trigger for a symptomatic UTI, which is also favored by
the changes in the urinary tract that occur during pregnancy. Several studies
indicate that during pregnancy untreated asymptomatic bacteriuria more
frequently leads to acute pyelonephitis. Preterm birth, adverse effects on
intrauterine growth, preeclampsia, hypertension and anemia may follow (4, 5).
Early diagnosis and prompt treatment of UTls are important to prevent
complications in the mother or fetus during pregnancy. For this reason, all
pregnant women should undergo a routine urine test at the first consultation.
To avoid risk to the fetus, the choice of antibiotic should be appropriate for
the week of pregnancy and is therefore rather limited: ampicillins and
cephalosporins remain in the front line and can be prescribed with little risk
to the fetus. Considerable disagreement surrounds the duration of antibiotic
treatment: studies with cephalexin (6) and amoxicillin (7) have shown that a
single dose given daily over 3-7 days is sufficient and is as good as
conventional therapy, although definitive resolution of the UTI is achieved in
only 70% of cases. An advantage of short-course therapy, however,is that it causes little or no effect on the vaginal flora.
Even when there are no symptoms or complaints, a urine test, including culture,
should be conducted 7-14 days after the antibiotic treatment at the latest and,
if infection persists, further differential and urological diagnosis should be
undertaken to exclude other causes such as urinary obstruction or urolithiasis.
If necessary, nitrofurantoin, e.g. 50 mg at night for 3-4 weeks should be
prescribed as long-term prophylaxis. However,this
preparation is contraindicated in the first 3 months of pregnancy and in the
last 4 weeks before delivery as it can cause hemolytic anemia in the fetus (8-11).
It is now possible to use immunostimulation with the bacterial extract OM-8930
to avoid unnecessary treatment with antibiotics and to improve prevention
against recurrence. In vitro and in vivo studies in animals and humans have
shown that this preparation triggers a series of immunopharmacological effects
(12-1 7). In particular, it increases the metabolic and functional activities
of lymphocytes and macrophages, the levels of urinary and intestinal secretory
IgA (slgA) and serum IgA and IgG, which are specific for E. coli and other
urinary pathogens. The aim of treatment is to improve the immune defenses in
the urogenital tract mucosa, i.e. to prevent bacterial adherence and thus
colonization in the region of the vagina and urethra. A particularly important
role is played by slgA, which is produced byplasma cells and bound via a
glycoprotein to the cells of the epithelium (18). It is now known that a
reduced slgA titer is a predisposing factor for recurrent UTls (2, 19, ). Several double-blind and open clinical studies have
shown that OM-8930 significantly reduces the risk of UTI recurrence, especially
that of cystitis, and improves laboratory parameters (bacteriuria,
leukocyturia) as well as clinical symptoms (dysuria) (2128), as confirmed in a
recent metaanalysis (29). Because all the preclinical toxicological and
teratogenic studies performed in embryos to date have shown no negative effects
of OM-8930 and the clinical trials have revealed a high therapeutic effect with
a very low incidence of mild and reversible adverse effects, the aim of the
present trial was to investigate the efficacy and safety of this extract in
preventing recurrent UTls in pregnant women.
Bacterial extract for the prevention of recurrent urinary tract infections in
pregnant women
Materials and methods
This open clinical pilot study on the efficacy and
safety of OM-8930 was conducted at six gynecological practices in Switzerland.
The test preparation OM-8930 is a lyophilized bacterial extract containing
immunoactive detoxified fractions of selected E. coli strains (Uro-Vaxom@, OM
PHARMA, Meyrin/Geneva, Switzerland). A total of
77 women with asymptomatic or acute symptomatic UTls in weeks 16-28 of
pregnancy were enrolled in the study. All the women were informed ofthe aims
and objectives of the study and gave their consent. Treatment with OM-8930, at
the recommended dosage of one capsule every morning on an empty stomach,
commenced concomitantly with antibiotic therapy and continued until the end of
pregnancy. Antibiotics were prescribed if necessary. Clinical checks were
conducted 1 week after the end of the initial antibiotic therapy and then
monthly until 6 weeks after delivery. Criteria for inclusion in the study were
a bacteriuria of >105/ml in midstream urine or 1 104/mlin urine collected by
catheter. Bacteriuria was demonstrated by using the following culture media:
cystine-lactoseelectrolyte-deficient medium for the determination of total germ
count (Gram-positive and Gram-negative) and McConkey medium for the selective count
of Gram-negative microorganisms. Exclusion criteria included preexisting
urological diseases such as urolithiasis or urinary obstruction, reduced renal
function (serum creatinine > 1.8 mg%), allergic
predisposition, treatment with other immunogenic preparations,known fetal
anomalies and known familial congenital malformations,among other criteria.
Efficacy was assessed on the basis of the number of UTI recurrences, short- and
long-term efficacy and antibiotic use compared with the 6 months prior to the start
of the study. Further parameters for efficacy included dysuria, bacteriuria,
the number of leukocytes and erythrocytes in the urine sediment
and demonstration of the presenceof albumin and nitrite. The short- and
long-term effects of OM-8930 were assessed subjectively by the investigating
physician on a 4-point scale (from 0 = no effect to 3 = certain effect) The
safety of the product was determined on the basis of the number, type, duration
and severity of the adverse effects occurring in the pregnant women and the
condition of the newborns (Apgar score). In the absence of an untreated control
group, the study data were compared with those from the 6month period prior to
the start of the study. Statistical comparison of the various parameters was achieved
using a time-adjusted coefficient to account for the fact that the two phases
were not identical in duration. The data from the 6-month reference period were
multiplied by the time-adjusted coefficient, which was derived by dividing the
duration of OM8930 therapy in days by 180 days (6 months). Statistical analysis
was performed by Biometrix SA (Gland, Switzerland) using the statistical software
SPSS+ release 5.0 (SPSS, Chicago, IL, USA),
NCSS release 7.0 (Number Cruncher Statistical System, Kaysville,
UT, USA)
and Testimate release 5.1 (Internationale Datenanalyse und Versuchsplanung,
Gauting/Munich, Germany).
The time-adjusted data for the study period and the prior reference period were
compared using the Wilcoxon rank test for paired data. The evolution of the
data between the start and the end of the study was also analyzed using the
Wilcoxon rank test for paired dataor the McNemar test for dichotomic paired
data.
Results
Of the 77 pregnant women enrolled in the study, 3 were excluded from the analysis
because of failure to comply with the study protocol. Among the remaining 74
patients, 12 did not meet the inclusion criteria: 10 because of bacteriuria of
< 104/ml and 2 as they were enrolled after week 28 of pregnancy, leaving 62
assessable patients. The pregnant women were aged 19-38 years (mean 26.9 [&
4.61 years). The number of previous births varied from zero (n = 19) to five (n
= 1) with a majority having had one birth (n = 29), followed by two (n = 9) and
three (n = 4). The main diagnoses at entry into the study are shown in Table I.
Thirty-six patients (58.1%) had cystitis; 20 patients (32.2%) had a UTI without
more precise indications, of whom only three (4.8%) were asymptomatic, and six
patients (9.7%) had pyelitis. As envisaged in the study protocol, treatment
commenced between weeks 16 and 28 of pregnancy (mean: week 23). The mean
treatment duration was 119 t 29 days. Patient compliance was assessed at each
visit on the basis of the remaining medication and was estimated, with one
exception, as 'good'. The efficacy of the bacterial extract was
determined on the basis of the number of recurrences during the study period
compared with that in the 6month phase prior to the start of the study. During
OM-8930 therapy there was a significant reduction (p = 0.002) inrecurrences
with only 12 patients (19.4%) suffering from UTI recurrences compared with 32
patients (52.5%,time-adjusted) in the previous 6
months (Fig. 1). A second important criterion was the number and duration of
antibiotic treatments, which were markedly reduced. Before the start of the
study 34 patients (55.7%, time-adjusted) required additional antibiotic therapy
compared with only 8 (12.9%) during OM8930 therapy (Fig. 2). Again, the
difference between the two phases was statistically significant = 0.0002).The
duration of antibiotic treatment was also reduced from a mean of 3.2 to 2 days
(p = 0.0016) (Table 11). In addition, dysuria, nitrituria, leukocyturia and
erythrocyturia also showed significant improvement from entry into the study
until 6 weeks after delivery
Acute cystitis Recurrent cystitis Acute pyelitis Recurrent pyelitis Acute UTI
Recurrent UTI Asymptomatic UTI
50.0 8.1 6.5 3.2 24.2 3.2 4.8
( < 0.001). The rate of dysuria fell from 87.1% to p 1.7% (Table Ill).
The subjective assessment of efficacy by the investigating physicians was
highly positive. They considered that the short- and long-term efficacy of
OM-8930 was certain or possible in 59 patients (95.2%).
p = 0.002
Before
After
UTI recurrences
Fig. 1 The number of patients with urinary tract infection(UTI)
recurrences (time-adjusted) before the start of the study and after OM-8930
therapy.
Bacterial extract for the prevention of recurrent urinary tract infections in
pregnant women
indicated an arterial pH of 7.20 (k 0.13) and a venous pH of 7.36 (k 0.06). No
malformations were found in the newborns.
Discussion
The efficacy and safety of OM-8930 have been demonstrated in various double
blind and open clinical studies (21-28). More than 1,000 patients participated
in these studies and were evaluated for both efficacy and tolerance, with the
following conclusions: the bacterial extract significantly reduced the number
of UTI recurrences and the need for antibiotic therapy, as well as bacteriuria,
leukocyturia and dysuria. These findings have been confirmed by a recent
metaanalysis (29). In the present open pilot study, the effect of the bacterial
extract was assessed in 62 patients in weeks 16-28 of pregnancy who presented
with asymptomatic or acute symptomatic UTI. The number of recurrences was significantly
reduced in comparison with the 6 months prior to the start of the study, i.e.
only 12 (19.4%) rather than 32 (52.5%) of the pregnant women experienced UTI
recurrences. Before treatment, 34 (55.7%) of the patients required antibiotics,
while during treatment this number fell to 8 (12.9%). In addition, the mean
duration of antibiotic administration fell from 3.2 to 2 days. Furthermore,
only1.7% of patients reported dysuria, compared with 87.1% before the start of
OM-8930 treatment. These results confirm once again the findings of earlier
studies.
Before After
Antibiotic therapy
Fig. 2 The number of patients undergoing antibiotic therapy (time-adjusted)
before the start of the study and after OM-8930 therapy.
Suspected adverse effects occurred only in 2 of the 74 patients (2.7%) of the
safety population and took the form of transient slight nausea or mild
heartburn. The patients were able to continue in the study despite these
effects, which the physicians considered to be probably due to the pregnancy
itself. The condition of the newborns was examined using the Apgar score, among
other measures. The mean Apgar score was 8.6/9.5/10.0. The mean birth weight
was 3,321 g (r427) and the mean length was 49.3 cm (? 2.03). Umbilical cord pH
measurements
Table II Comparison of the average duration of antibiotic administration (in
days, time-adjusted) During the 6 months prior to the start of the study (in
days
Parameter Duration of antibiotic administration
During OM-8930 therapy (in days)
2.0
Comparison p-value
0.0016
Baertschi R.et al.
Table 111 Evolution of dysuria during OM-8930 therapy
Number of patients Consultation Entry 1 week after the end of the initial
antibiotic 1 month after the start of the study 3 months after the start of the
study 6 weeks after deliveryNumber
62 57 59 52 58
Concerning safety, only two patients (2.7%) reported symptoms that could be
regarded as adverse effects (slight nausea and mild heartburn) and no negative
effects were observed in the newborns. On the basis of the different studies
performed to date, the tolerance of OM-8930 can be classified as good: only 4%
of patients developed adverse effects, most of which were gastrointestinal
symptoms and skin reactions. None of these events was considered serious.
Interactions with other medications have not been observed to date.
Furthermore, preclinical embryotoxicity and teratogenicity studies showed no
risk to the fetus. Clinical examination showed that the newborns in this study
were without exception normal (size, birth weight, malformation). There were no
problems with neonatal adaptation (umbilicalpH values, Apgar score). No
controlled studies with this bacterial extract in pregnant women are as yet
available. However, on the basis of currently available data and knowledge, the
use of OM-8930 after week 16 of pregnancy appears to present no risk to the
fetus. In conclusion, although these findings should be confirmed in large
controlled trials, the present data indicate that the administration of OM-8930
for UTls during pregnancy reduces the number of recurrences. This has the
advantage of minimizing the use of antibiotics, whichis often regarded as complicated
during pregnancy because of the potential risk to
the unborn child. With timely and adequate treatment of UTls, pregnancy
complications such as preterm birth, adverse effects on intrauterine growth,
preeclampsia, hypertension and anemia can be reduced or prevented (4, 5). In
the long term, prompt treatment and prevention could also reduce the risk of
UTls becoming chronic and of sequelae such as chronic pyelonephritis and renal
insufficiency.
Acknowledgments
OM PHARMA (Meyrin/Geneva, Switzerland)
contributed to the costs of laboratory analyses.
References
(1) Foxman B. Epidemiology of urinary tract infections: Incidence, morbidityand
economic costs. Am. J. Med., 113 (Suppl. l A ) , 5s,
2002. (2) Engel J.D., Schaeffer A.J. Evaluation of and antimicrobial therapy
for recurrent urinary tract infections in women. Urol. Clin. North Am., 25,
685, 1998. (3) Stamm W.E., Hooton T M . Management of
urinary tract infections in adults N . Engl. J. Med.,
329, 1328, 1993 (4) Romero R., Oyarzun E , Mazor M , et al Meta-analysis of the
relationship between symptomatic bacterium and pre-term deliveryilow birth
weight. Obstet Gynecol. , 576, 1989.
Bacterial extract for the prevention of recurrent urinary tract infections in
pregnant women
(5) Wang E., Srnaill F. lnfection in pregnancy. In: Chalrners I., Enkin M . , Keirse M.J. (Eds.). 'Effective
Care in Pregnancy and Childbirth'. Oxford
University Press, Oxford, 1990,pp.
535-538. (6) McFayden IR Campbell-Brown M . , Stephenson M . , et al. Single-dose treatment of bacteriuria in pregnancy.
Eur. J. Urol., 13 (Suppl. l ) , 22, 1987. (7)
Masterton R.G.,Evans
D.C., Strike PW. Single-dose
amoxycillin in the treatment of bacteriuria in pregnancy and puerperium - a
controlled clinical trial. Br. J. Obstet. Gynaecol., 92,498, 1985. (8)
Chauveau D . , Jungers P, Grunfeld J.P Urinary tract
infections during pregnancy Diagnosis, course, prognosis and treatment. Rev.
Prat., 47, 1933, 1997. (9) Hall D.R.,Theron G.B.,van
der Horst W. Significance and treatment of asymptomatic bacteriuria during
pregnancy Int. J . Gynaecol. Obstet.,
57, 179, 1997. (10) MacLean A.B. Urinary tract infection in pregnancy. Br. J. Urol., 80 (Suppl. I ) , 10,
1997. (1 1) Patterson T E , Andriole VT Detection,
significance, and therapy of bacteriuria In pregnancy Update in the managed
health care era. Infect. Dis. Clin. North Am., 11, 593, 1997. (12) Bosch A.,
Benedi V.J., Pares R., et al. Enhancement of the humoral immune response and
resistance to bacterial infection in mice by the oral administration of a
bacterial immunomodulator (OM-89). Irnrnunopharrnacol.
Irnmunotoxicol., 10, 333, 1988. (13) Huber M . , Baier W., Serr A., et al. lmmunogenicify of an E. col;
extract after oral or intraperitonealadministration: lnduction of antibodies
against pathogenic bacterial strains. Int J . Irnmunopharrnacol., 22 57, 2000. (14) Pham Van T , Kreis
B.,Corradin-Betz S., et al Metabolic and functional stimulation of lymphocytes
and macrophages by an Escherichia col; extract (OM-89): In wtro studies. J . Biol. Resp. Modifiers, 9, 231, 1990. (15) Riedasch G.,
Kalbe T , Mohring K . Vaccination
therapy of recurrent urinary tract infections of girls with UroVaxom. Zschr. Antimikrob. Antineopl.
Chemother.,Suppl. 1 , A257, 1989. (16)Wybran J., Libin
M . , Schandene L. Enhancement of cytokine production
and natural killer activity by an €schenchia col; extract. Onkologie, 12 (Suppl. 3), 22, 1989. (17) Schmidhammer S.,
Ramoner R., Hoelth L., et al. An Escherichia coli-based oral vaccine against
respiratory tract
infections potently activates human dendritic cells. Urol.,
60, 521, 2002. (1 8) Schneider H.J. lmmunstimulation: Neuer
Therapieansatz be; rezidivierenden Harnwegsinfekten. Der Allgemeinarzt, 12,
626, 1990. (19) James-Ellison M.Y., Roberts R., Verrier-Jones K. et al. Mucosal
immunity in the urinary tract: Changes in slgA, FSC and total lgA with age and
in urinary tract infection. Clin Nephrol., 48, 69, 1997. (20) Riedasch G.,
Mohring K. lmmuntherapeutikum beugt Rezidivien vor. Urolog.
Nephrolog
(21) Frey C., Obolensky W.,Wyss H. Treatment
ofrecurrent urinary tract infections: Efficacy of an orally administered
biological response modifier Urol Int., 41, 444, 1986 (22) Hachen H . J . Oral immunotherapy in paraplegic patients with chronic
unnary tract infections: A double-blind, placebo-controlledtrial. J . Urol., 143, 759, 1990 (23) Lettgen B.
Prevention of recurrent urinary tract infections in female children.
OM-89 immunotherapy compared with nitrofurantoin prophylaxis /n a randomized
pilot study. Curr. Therap. Res., 57,
463, 1996. (24) Magasi P , Panovisc J., llles
A., et al. Uro-Vaxom@ and the management of recurrent urinary tract infection
in adults: A randomized multicenter double-blind trial. Eur. Urol., 26,137,
1994. (25) Rugendorff E .W. lrnmunological therapy of recurrent urinary tract
infections with immunoactive E. col; fractions in women. Int. Urogynecol. J . , 3, 179, 1992. (26) Schulmann C.C., Corbusier A.,
Michiels H . , et al. Oral immunotherapy of recurrent
urinary tract infections: A double-blind placebo-controlled study of OM-8930 in
recurrent unnary tract infections conducted in Belgium and in the Federal Repubic
of Germany. J. Urol., 150,917, 1993. (27) Tamrnen H .
, Frey C. Treatment of recurrent urinary tract infections with Uro-Vaxom: Open
multicenter study with 527 patients. Urologe (B), 28,294, 1988. (28) Tammen H.
and the German Urinary Tract Infection Study Group. lmmunobiothempy
with Uro-Vaxom in recurrent unnary tract infection. Br. J .
Urol., 65 , 1990. (29) Bauer H.W.,Volker W.R.,
Lauener PA., et al. Prevention of recurrent urinary tract infections with
immunoactive E. coli fractions. A metaanalysIs of five
placebo-controlled double-blind studies. Int. J .
Antimicrobial. Agents, 19, 451,
2002.